It would require providers to assign each customer a unique meter number, monitor usage, convert it into readable details and issue invoices based on consumption.The debate has intensified as the National Assembly’s Departmental Committee on Communication, Information and Innovation considers the legislation.
The regulator has urged legislators not to make metered billing compulsory, while Telkom Kenya has warned of potential consequences for privacy, affordability and investment.The International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) Kenya has questioned the necessity of mandatory metering, arguing that the regulator already has powers to address billing complaints and protect consumers.Demas Kiprono of ICJ Kenya has argued that the proposed system raises questions about whether the collection of identifiable usage….
Opponents of the Bill say Parliament should make clear how those protections would apply to the proposed metering system.Questions about telecommunications data have also featured in court proceedings involving university student David Ooga Mokaya.He was arrested in November 2024 over a social media post concerning President William Ruto and charged with publishing false information.
On February 19 this year, Senior Principal Magistrate Caroline Nyaguthii acquitted him under Section 215 of the Criminal Procedure Code, finding that the prosecution had not proved its case beyond reasonable doubt.On February 25, Justice Bahati Mwamuye issued interim conservatory orders restraining the respondents and interested parties from transferring, sharing or disclosing Mokaya’s personal data without his written consent, a valid court order or an express provision of written law….
They do not establish that the proposed internet metering system would be used for surveillance.
They do, however, illustrate the legal questions that can arise over the collection and disclosure of telecoms data.Privacy is not the only concern.
Mandatory consumption-based billing could also affect how households and businesses budget for connectivity.In a submission to parliament on November 3, the Communications Authority cautioned against making metered billing compulsory across the sector.
It said the approach could have unintended consequences for affordability, digital inclusion and consumer choice, particularly among low-income households, students, small businesses and communities in underserved areas.The regulator noted that
applications, software updates, streaming and cloud services can consume data without users closely monitoring their usage.The Authority’s position is that consumer protection can be strengthened through regulations and licensing requirements without requiring every provider to adopt consumption-based pricing.The financial….
Customers who consume relatively little data could benefit from paying according to usage, while those who rely on large or continuous data allowances could face different costs.
The Bill does not set the retail prices providers would charge.Telecommunications companies have questioned whether the proposed changes could impose additional costs on providers and affect investment in broadband services.Telkom Kenya Chief Executive Officer Mugo Kibati told the parliamentary committee on November 10 that mobile internet accounts for about 96 percent of data subscriptions and is already billed by volume.
The proposed changes would therefore mainly affect fixed broadband services, which account for the remaining share, he said.Carole Kairuki, chief executive of the Kenya Private Sector Alliance, also raised concerns about the potential effect of mandatory metering on businesses.
In an interview with Al Jazeera, she said changes to internet billing could increase compliance costs and make connectivity expenses less predictable for businesses, particularly smaller enterprises.The Bill’s memorandum says the proposed amendments are intended to protect consumers from exploitation and secure their economic interests under Article 46 of the Constitution.
It also states that the legislation does not limit fundamental rights and freedoms.The debate comes amid wider public scrutiny of digital rights and the handling of online activity in Kenya, particularly following the 2024 protests against the Finance Bill.

Pakistan · World · Independent Digital Newsroom
