Asad Dandia was eight when he watched the September 11, 2001 attacks on television at his Pakistani immigrant parents’ home in New York.
Then came the backlash — years of Islamophobia as Americans processed attacks that had killed nearly 3,000 people.
There was anger, suspicion and worse.
At 19, Dandia experienced a police informant posing as a friend to infiltrate his family home, part of a now-disgraced surveillance effort purportedly seeking to detect extremism.
Today, though, the 33-year-old historian finds a New York transformed: one with its first Muslim mayor, public prayers in Times Square and new mosques rising across the city.
“Twenty-five years after 9/11, we mourn, and we grieve what happened, and at the same time, we recognise that I am not responsible for what happened,” he told AFP.
“I don’t deserve to be targeted for what happened, and I am as much of a New Yorker as anybody else in that respect,” said Dandia, who leads walking tours centred on the city’s Muslim communities.
Islamophobia surged in the United States after the 2001 attacks in which militants hijacked airliners and flew them into Manhattan’s World Trade Centre and the Pentagon outside Washington. A fourth plane crashed into a Pennsylvania field after a passenger revolt.
Muslims reported increased public assaults and harassment, and some stopped wearing visual markers such as hijabs in a bid to conceal their religion.
Meanwhile, US authorities monitored Muslims by requiring thousands of men and boys to register with the government, leading to many being deported from the country.
“Everyone was in such fear,” said Pakistan-born Mohammad Razvi, who founded the Council of Peoples Organisation nonprofit to support Muslims in New York after 9/11.
“We had gunshots fired in our neighbourhood by individuals who felt that we were responsible,” he added.
“Muslims trying to live the American dream were being blamed for something they had nothing to do with or even control,” he said.
‘Terrifying’
In New York, police began surveilling hundreds of Muslims as part of their counterterrorism strategy, often targeting people without evidence of wrongdoing.
Dandia experienced this as a 19-year-old college student, when a young Bangladeshi man joined a mutual aid charity he had started.
The pair grew close: sharing meals, playing sports and even sleeping at Dandia’s home. But seven months later, the man revealed that he was an NYPD informant sent to monitor Dandia and his community.
“It was heartbreaking, but it was also terrifying,” he recalled. “My relationship with the world around me shifted underneath my feet.”
After his ordeal, Dandia and rights groups won a landmark legal settlement that restricted the NYPD from launching similar surveillance programmes and established a watchdog to monitor the force.
For Gadier Abbas, an attorney with the Council on American-Islamic Relations, the NYPD programme was the prime example of the “anti-Muslim hysteria” that followed 9/11.
But today, Abbas said, “there is a lot of hope.”
“You see American Muslims in every single walk of life, almost at every single level, and that’s a testament to the vibrancy of the community.”
‘Power’
New York will soon boast the largest mosque in the state — one of more than 100 added since 2001 in New York — while Muslims are a rising cultural and political force.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who took his oath of office on the Holy Quran, has become the new face of American leftist politics.
Still, Islamophobia persists in the city where around 9% of the population is Muslim.
In March, a far-right influencer organised a “Stop the Islamic Takeover of New York City” rally outside the mayor’s residence.
Meanwhile, a conservative senator has said Mamdani should be sent to Guantanamo Bay, the US detention camp best known for holding 9/11 suspects.
Rudy Giuliani, who was mayor of the city during the attacks, said it “offends me” that Mamdani will attend the 9/11 memorial service, and some relatives of victims have called for him to stay away, while other families have defended the mayor.
Dandia acknowledged Islamophobia had not disappeared, but he was optimistic about how far New York’s Muslim community has come.
“I’ve seen the growth of our institutional power, but also the recognition by other New Yorkers who are not Muslim, that we are all part of this city together,” he said.
“I think that’s really valuable because, you know, Rome was not built overnight, and it was not built by one person or one group of people. It was built by the community.”
